By M.K. Horwitt et al.
Summary: Report of a controlled study conducted in a state hospital testing the effects of diets deficient in thiamine and riboflavin. Of course this kind of test could never be conducted under today’s ethical standards. Nevertheless, as expected, those who were starved of various vitamins suffered noticeable effects and recovered when they were restored to a proper diet. From Science, 1946. Lee Foundation for Nutritional Research reprint 26.
[The following is a transcription of the original Archives document. To view or download the original document, click here.]
Studies of Vitamin Deficiency
Biochemical, clinical, neurological, and psychological investigations were conducted on the subjects of this study who were patients in the Elgin State Hospital. The experimental design was such that the effects of diets restricted in their contents of thiamine and riboflavin for three full years could be continuously observed. A special building housed the patients, and very satisfactory facilities were provided for continuous supervision and rigid control of diets. All food was prepared in a diet kitchen adequately staffed with full-time workers. The diets were analyzed frequently, and the service was so arranged that the subjects of separate groups were served separately. Care was taken that the patients were not harmed by the diets or the study. The more important observations are reported here in brief. A full report is contemplated later.
Thirty-six male patients were selected from the [Elgin] State Hospital population. The need for persons who would be in continued residence for a prolonged period of time influenced the selection. The subjects were divided into two main groups: (1) patients whose ages ranged from 58 to 78 years and (2) younger patients, who were from 24 to 42 years of age. Each of these groups was divided into three subgroups, designated as groups A, B, and C, respectively. At the beginning of the project, there were three groups of seven old men and three groups of five young men. Each person in the A groups received a daily diet containing approximately 2,200 calories, which was apparently adequate in all the essentials except thiamine, of which approximately 400 μg were present, and riboflavin, of which the diet contained about 900 μg. Those in the B groups received the same diet except that a daily supplement of yeast extract was given that contained approximately 6 mg of thiamine and 1.3 mg of riboflavin. The members of the C groups received the regular hospital diet, which they ate ad libitum.
The clinical effect of this moderate restriction of thiamine and riboflavin on subjects of the A groups was at no time more than minimal. Noticeable, however, in these subjects, young and old, was a gradually increasing self-imposed restriction of activity, a dulling of interest and of ambition, a diminished desire to please, and a lessened tendency to bantering and playfulness. The statement applies to the general behavior of the subjects when left alone. Attempts to measure these changes of behavior by psychological tests were thwarted to a large extent by compensations effected when the subjects were confronted by the conditions of the tests. The skin of several subjects of the younger group became thinner and lost elasticity, these changes imparting an appearance of aging. The lips showed drying, thinning, and increased wrinkling. A more objective abnormality, noted within nine months from the beginning of the diet and persisting for more than two years, was an unusual elevation in the levels of lactic and pyruvic acids in blood obtained under standardized conditions of exercise and glucose load. Some abnormality in the levels of lactic and pyruvic acids in the blood occurred within the first three months.
At the beginning of the third year of the study, the subjects of both B groups, whose diets previously had been supplemented with yeast extract, were placed on a diet that was more rigidly restricted in content of thiamine and riboflavin than the diets of the subjects of the A groups. This provided 200 μg of thiamine and 800 μg of riboflavin. Among the subsequent observations of these subjects were the following:
1. The levels of lactic and pyruvic acids in the blood were elevated under the standardized condition of exercise and glucose load. The standardized condition referred to consisted of climbing of stairs 60 minutes after ingestion of 1.8 g of glucose/kg of body weight. The concentration of lactic and pyruvic acids in the blood was increased more than in the subjects of the A groups, whose intake of thiamine was moderately restricted. This became apparent about three months after the diet of 200 μg of thiamine was started and was followed shortly by the development of clear-cut clinical evidence of thiamine deficiency.
2. Effects on the circulation, nervous system, and gastrointestinal tract were acute to subacute in onset. Among the circulatory effects was a nonpitting swelling of the facial skin, especially of the eyelids, which could be observed in subjects who did not develop pitting edema of the lower extremities. Budding of the blood vessels into the cornea with plexus formation in its periphery also was observed in a few subjects. Mental changes were characterized chiefly by loss of inhibitory control and a tendency to interpret distressing somatic changes in a paranoid fashion.
3. A diagnostic tool that proved useful was an apparatus designed to study vibration sense. This apparatus made it possible to apply various frequencies to the external malleolus and the soft part of the big toe. The amplitude of the vibration was kept constant. The vibration sense in the lower extremities decreased markedly as the nutritional deficiency progressed.
4. Psychologically, the patients on the more deficient diets (200 μg of thiamine/day) manifested exaggerations of their psychotic complaints and showed distinct changes in attitudes toward their environment.
5. Marked individual differences in response to the diets were observed in both old and young groups, not only in time of onset of symptoms but also in the degree of resulting abnormality. The subjects who gave evidence of vitamin deficiency early manifested abnormalities that were greater in degree than those observed in others who were affected more slowly. This was especially true with respect to the cardiovascular system. In general the older persons were affected earlier and more severely than were the younger.
Recovery when yeast extract providing 6 mg of supplementary thiamine was added to the diet was dramatic, especially in the subjective fields of appetite, general feeling tone, pain, and paresthesia. The levels of lactic and pyruvic acids after the standardized conditions of exercise and glucose rapidly returned to their predeficiency levels. Likewise, patellar reflexes that had been lost commenced to return soon after the yeast extract was added to the diet. On the other hand, return of the Achilles tendon reflex was very slow.
By M.K. Horwitt, Erich Liebert, Oscar Kreisler, and Phyllis Wittman. Elgin State Hospital, Elgin, Illinois. Sponsored by the Committee on Nutritional Aspects of Aging, Food and Nutrition Board, National Research Council. The project was supported by the Josiah Macy Jr. Foundation and the Milbank Memorial Fund. Reprinted by the Lee Foundation for Nutritional Research, with permission, from Science, Vol. 104, No. 2705, November 1946.
Reprint No. 26
Lee Foundation for Nutritional Research
Milwaukee, WI 53201
Note: Lee Foundation for Nutritional Research is a nonprofit, public-service institution, chartered to investigate and disseminate nutritional information. The attached publication is not literature or labeling for any product, nor shall it be employed as such by anyone. In accordance with the right of freedom of the press guaranteed to the Foundation by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the attached publication is issued and distributed for informational purposes.